In short: A price negotiation is won by whoever prepares earlier, names a well-founded price first and makes no concession without something in return. That applies to the seller who wants to push through a price increase just as much as to the buyer who has to fend it off. The difference is not in the role, but in the preparation.
We sit on both sides of this table. An FMCG supplier we supported increased its margin by 15% in its annual negotiations with retailers. And 153 procurement professionals we trained in 2025 saved €143,758 per person on average.
| Phase | As a seller (pushing through a price increase) | As a buyer (fending off a price increase) |
|---|---|---|
| Preparation | Know the customer’s costs, value and alternatives, months before the round | Set your own target prices and alternatives before the increase arrives |
| Opening | Name a well-founded, ambitious price first | Make your own proposal instead of arguing about the offer |
| Justification | Show value and market developments, not your own cost calculation | Do not ask for a justification, it only hands over arguments |
| Concessions | Only in exchange for something: volume, contract term, payment terms | Only in exchange for something: service, conditions, exclusivity |
| Closing | Phrase it firmly, no back door | Set the timetable yourself, not the supplier’s |
Most price negotiations are lost before anyone enters the room. If you only start two weeks before the annual negotiation, all you can do is react. Good preparation means: segmenting customers or suppliers, setting goals per negotiation, setting expectations early and honestly assessing the balance of power. Why this ideally starts before the summer is explained by Christian Gasser in Annual Price Indexations: Start before the summer
The first offer is the reference point against which everything else is measured. If you wait, you negotiate on the other side’s turf. But an ambitious first price only works if you can justify it. Without justification it is a provocation. More on this in The power of the extreme opening.
Every discount you give without something in return sends a signal: there is more to be had. Professional negotiators trade. One percent on price in exchange for longer payment terms, a higher purchase volume or a longer contract term. Prepare these trade-offs before the meeting, not during it. Then under pressure you do not react on impulse, but according to plan.
“We were thinking of about 5%” invites renegotiation. “Our price will be 5% higher from 1 January” does not. Experienced buyers hear every “possibly” and every “we could” and push exactly there. Which phrases to cut is shown in Weak language & firm proposals.
When a supplier announces a price increase, even experienced procurement teams often react the same way. Three mistakes keep coming back:
Martin Pilch explains all three in detail in Price Increase Pitfalls.
Price negotiation is not a talent. It is preparation and practice. Three results from our engagements:
And on the procurement side: 153 procurement professionals, 4 companies, €21.99 million in savings in 2025, measured with the clients’ own trackers.
How do I prepare for a price negotiation?
Set your target, your walk-away point and your alternatives before you talk to the other side. Prepare trade-offs: what do you give, and what do you want for it? And start months before the actual round, not days.
Should I name a price first in a price negotiation?
Usually yes, if you know the market and can justify your price. The first offer sets the anchor. If you lack information, ask questions first.
How do I respond to a price increase from my supplier?
Do not ask for a justification; make your own well-founded proposal instead. And set the timetable yourself rather than waiting for the next letter.
How much discount should I give?
None without something in return. Every discount should be traded for something that has value for you: volume, contract term, payment terms or exclusivity.
The rules of a price negotiation fit on one page. Applying them when the buyer goes silent or the supplier threatens to stop deliveries is something else. That is exactly what we train, using your real price rounds as the case study. For sales teams in our negotiation training for sales, for procurement teams in our procurement negotiation training. More techniques at a glance: Negotiation techniques: what really works at the negotiating table.
Our Negotiation Consulting services leverage a proven, successful methodology to deliver exceptional outcomes. We empower our clients either through direct support (consulting) or long-lasting capability development to achieve the best possible results in every negotiation.